Landlords and property managers
Wall Repairs Between Tenants: A Turnover Guide for Shiloh Rentals
A rental turnover in Shiloh usually has a short window: the old tenant's move-out date, a cleaning, any repairs and paint, and the new tenant's move-in date. Drywall repair sits in the middle of that sequence and holds up everything after it if it is left late. This guide covers what to look for, how to order the work and how to decide between a patch and a full repaint.
1. Walk the unit with a list
Walk every room on the day the unit is empty, with good light and a phone camera. Look at each wall at an angle, not straight on; low light across a wall shows dents and patches that a straight look misses. Check behind every door for a doorknob hole, the ceiling line for nail pops, outside corners in hallways, the wall beside the bed, and anywhere a TV or shelf was mounted.
Write each item down with its room and an approximate size. Photograph it twice, close and wide. Those photos serve as the record of the unit's condition at move-out and as the description for anyone pricing the repair.
2. Sort the damage
Most turnover damage falls into three groups. Small marks, such as picture-nail holes and light scuffs, are usually normal wear and are handled during painting. Repairable damage, such as anchor holes, doorknob holes, gouges, torn paper and crushed corner bead, needs a drywall repair before paint. Damage with a cause behind it, such as a water stain, a crack that keeps returning or a soft spot, needs the cause found first.
Keep the groups separate on the list. It makes the quote easier to read and keeps a small job from being priced like a large one.
3. Put the work in the right order
The order between tenants is: fix any leaks or other causes, repair the drywall, let it dry, prime, paint, then clean. Joint compound cures one coat at a time, and cold or damp weather stretches each wait. In a Shiloh winter, when outdoor lows average below freezing from December through February, keep the heat on in a vacant unit so the compound dries and the paint cures.
Book the drywall repair as soon as the move-out date is known, not after the unit is empty. The walk-through can often happen while the tenant is still packing, and the repair can start the day after they leave. Give the drywall work a head start of several days before the painter.
4. Deciding how much to repaint
A patch can be touched up and left, with no full-wall repaint, when the paint color and sheen are known and the wall is flat or matte. Keep a labeled can of each color used in the unit, or a list of the color names and sheens, for this reason.
Repaint the full wall, corner to corner, when the paint has faded, when the sheen is satin or eggshell, or when there are several patches on the same wall. A touch-up on a faded or glossy wall shows as a brighter or shinier square. Many landlords repaint the full unit at every second or third turnover and touch up in between.
5. Cut down the next round of damage
Door stops behind every swinging door prevent the most common hole. Metal or vinyl corner guards on busy hallway corners take the knocks. A short note in the lease or move-in sheet about which wall anchors are allowed, and where, cuts down on anchor holes. Fixing nail pops at turnover, while the rooms are empty, is easier than working around a tenant's furniture later.
6. What it typically costs
Fixr's national cost guide puts general drywall repair at roughly $200 to $550, the repair of holes at roughly $60 to $200, and nail pop repair at roughly $75 to $140. These ranges cover the whole country, not this county. For a rental, the number and size of repairs, texture, corner bead, and how many trips the drying requires decide the price. Grouping every repair in the unit into one job is usually the most efficient approach. The details on patching a unit before the next move-in cover the repair methods in more depth.
7. Quick sort table
| Damage | Group | Usual repair |
|---|---|---|
| Picture-nail holes | Usually wear | Filled during paint prep |
| Anchor and mount holes | Repair | Filled with setting compound, sanded, primed |
| Doorknob hole | Repair | Backed patch, taped, textured; add a door stop |
| Crushed corner | Repair | Corner bead replaced, coated, primed |
| Water stain | Find the cause | Leak fixed, stain sealed or board replaced |
| Returning crack | Find the cause | Retaped; structure checked if it keeps moving |